Adrian,
an alien, has occupied the body of an Englishman in order to find another human
body that contains his leader, Menonan. He travels to Ephraim, Wisconsin to
find a man he forced to help in a failed attempt to track down Menonan twenty
years earlier. There he discovers that a young woman, Laura, is the key to his
success this time. Thus begins Adrian’s stalker-like attempts to convince Laura
that she has no choice but to help him. In addition to Adrian’s creepy
behavior, Laura must deal with an overbearing father, a lecherous boss, the
wife of the now-dead Englishman in whose body Adrian resides, the wife’s
detective friend, the police, various townsfolk who know what’s going on but won’t
divulge their secrets, and a younger sister who wants to help but is mostly
just a pain in the ass.
The
central premise of Escape from Eternity
– Earth as a place created and used by a race of eternal beings to recover from
the boredom of eternity – is an interesting concept with a lot of story
potential. Unfortunately, Scholze falls short of delivering on that potential.
The idea is presented in a piecemeal fashion that leaves more questions than
answers. Some of those questions, when raised by Laura, are answered with a, “That’s
just the way it is” kind of answer. That isn’t acceptable to Laura, nor should
it be to the reader.
One
problem I have with the story is the number of times Adrian has to try to
explain to the same people the nature of earth and his mission here. This
lengthens the book unnecessarily and becomes very tedious. I suppose this could
be a device for demonstrating Adrian’s commitment to his mission. If so, that
could be more effectively shown by better developing his alien personality.
All
of the characters are inconsistent. I like well-written characters who are
confused and troubled. I’m not a fan of characters who are confusing. Even when
they’re confused or uncertain about something, there has to be a core value or
trait that directs everything they do. Scholze’s characters don’t have that.
They react and behave in whatever manner best fits the plot twist of the
moment.
The
story includes a fairly graphic description of a sexual assault. The outcome of
the assault is important to the plot, but it could be accomplished by any of
several other means that would be less invasive to the story.
Overall,
Escape from Eternity feels like
several lumps of clay that a sculptor has thrown onto a frame, but hasn’t yet
begun molding into a pleasing form.
2
of 5 Stars
380
Pages
Published
May 2012 by Outskirts Press
Nate Scholze's Website